Earth Breeze vs Tru Earth: Which Eco-Friendly Laundry Detergent Is Right For You?
If you’re passionate about creating a more sustainable household, you know how quickly little things like plastic bottles can add up!
The most frustrating part is that many products, such as laundry detergent, don’t need to be packaged in plastic at all. It’s just what we (and the laundry detergent industry) have grown used to!
Earth Breeze and Tru Earth are two of the leading brands of eco-friendly laundry detergent available today. Both are committed to eliminating plastic waste and reducing shipping emissions without sacrificing convenience and cleaning power.
Before we go on to a detailed comparison between the two brands, below is a quick comparison table that might help you:
Earth Breeze vs Tru Earth — A Comparison
| Earth Breeze | Tru Earth | |
|---|---|---|
| Formulas | Fresh Scent, Fragrance-Free | Fresh Linen, Fragrance-Free, Baby, Platinum Fresh Linen, Platinum Fragrance-Free |
| Loads Per Pack | 60 | Different options 64 is the most popular |
| Average Price Per Load | $0.33 ($0.22 with subscription) | $0.62 ($0.45 price for subscription, based on 64 sheets/pack) |
| Packaging | Recyclable, compostable cardboard | Recyclable, compostable paper |
| # of Ingredients | 8 (excluding fragrance) | 12 (excluding fragrance) |
| Shelf Life | Up to 18 months | Up to 3 years |
| Satisfaction Guarantee? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Plastic-Free? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Vegan? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Tested On Animals? | ✖ | ✖ |
| Gluten-Free? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Hypoallergenic? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Septic-Safe? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Safe for High-Efficiency Washers? | ✔ | ✔ |
| Safe for Greywater? | ✔ | — |
| Safe for Handwashing? | ✔ | ✔ |
After trying both brands, my verdict is that they are extremely similar products. One of the small points of difference is the price. Earth Breeze is a bit cheaper!
Another point of difference is the manufacturing location: Earth Breeze is made in China while Tru Earth is made in Canada – which is very rare. Another option, if local production is important to you Dropps is a US-made brand you should look into. For more details, check out our article Earth Breeze vs Dropps.
Check out our quick review video – Earth Breeze vs Tru Earth
Want to know more details? Want to give one of these brands a try for yourself? Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right formula for you!
What Are Laundry Detergent Sheets And How Do They Work?
Dissolvable laundry detergent sheets, like those offered by Earth Breeze and Tru Earth, are an eco-friendly alternative to traditional detergent formulas.
The best thing about these laundry detergent sheets is that they don’t require bulky plastic packaging. They produce less post-consumer waste and fewer transportation emissions than the liquid or powder detergents available at your local supermarket.
At first, the concept of laundry detergent in the form of a sheet can seem odd. But if you’ve used laundry detergent pods before, you’re already familiar with dissolvable detergent!
Earth Breeze and Tru Earth sheets work in both hot and cold water. Just place the sheets in your washer and press start!
Earth Breeze
Earth Breeze
A plastic-free alternative to liquid laundry detergent.
Earth Breeze is an Oregon-based company offering a plastic-free alternative to liquid laundry detergent in the form of its laundry sheets. For more in-depth information, check out our Earth Breeze review.
Formulas
There are currently two formulas of Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets available: Fresh Scent and Fragrance-Free.
The ingredients for these two formulas are identical. The only difference is that, as the name implies, the Fragrance-Free version does not include added fragrance.
Ingredients
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets contain just 9 ingredients (or 8, if you opt for the Fragrance-Free version). This is far fewer ingredients than the vast majority of laundry detergents — eco-friendly and not — available on the market!
While Earth Breeze deserves kudos for eliminating unnecessary ingredients, this detergent is not 100% sustainable.
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets contain polyvinyl alcohol and polyethylene glycol — water-soluble petroleum byproducts.
Since these ingredients are water-soluble, there is no evidence that they harm the environment when disposed of via wastewater. But producing petroleum-based products in the first place is a large contributor to pollution and other environmental concerns.
Cost
A single package of Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets costs $20 and can clean up to 60 loads of laundry. Signing up for a no-contract subscription lowers the price to $12.95 per package. You can get 40% discount by clinking the link below:
Of course, total cost means very little in the world of laundry detergent. What really matters is the cost per load.
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets cost an average of 33 cents per load (or 22 cents with a subscription). This is comparable to most laundry formulas sold at the supermarket!
Packaging
All Earth Breeze packaging is 100% plastic-free! Instead, this laundry detergent is packaged in lightweight cardboard envelopes.
Once the envelope is empty, Earth Breeze packaging can be safely recycled or composted with other paper products.
Availability
Both formulas of Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets are available through the Earth Breeze website and popular online retailers like Amazon.
Earth Breeze products are sold in select brick-and-mortar stores. But there is currently no quick and easy way to find retailers in a specific area.
Where is Earth Breeze made? Where is the company location?
Earth Breeze is manufactured in China. The company headquarters and warehouse are in Oregon. They also have a UK warehouse for UK local shipping.
Brand Initiatives
Earth Breeze donates 10 loads of laundry supplies to charities and non-profits for each package of Laundry Sheets sold.
As a company, Earth Breeze participates in ocean clean-up and reforestation efforts. Earth Breeze also partners with sustainability organizations like We Are Neutral and 1% for the Planet in an effort to lower its carbon footprint.
Tru Earth
Tru Earth
A gentle, fragrance-free formula specially designed for parents and their young children.
Tru Earth is a British Columbia-based company offering a variety of eco-friendly alternatives to household products, including its popular Eco Strips laundry detergent.
Formulas
Tru Earth Eco Strips are available in several different formulas to meet a variety of needs.
The Fresh Linen and Fragrance-Free Eco Strips are the brand’s original formula. The only difference between the two versions is scented vs unscented.
Tru Earth Baby Eco-Strips are a gentle, fragrance-free formula specially designed for parents and their young children.
Finally, the Tru Earth Platinum Eco-Strips (available in Fresh Linen and Fragrance-Free versions) are ultra-concentrated detergent formulated for heavily soiled laundry, including sweaty activewear.
Ingredients
All Tru Earth Eco Strips are formulated with 12 standard ingredients. Scented Eco Strips also include fragrance, for 13 ingredients total.
While Tru Earth Eco Strips include a larger number of ingredients, the company does a good job of labeling each with its source and purpose. Tru Earth also provides safety data for its original and Platinum formulas.
Nearly all Tru Earth ingredients are plant-derived. However, like Earth Breeze, this laundry detergent does include petroleum-derived polyvinyl alcohol.
Cost
Tru Earth Eco Strips cost $19.95 per 32-load package. With a subscription, each package costs only $12.95.
This comes out to 62 cents per load of laundry. Subscribers pay approximately 40 cents per load.
According to these numbers, Tru Earth Eco Strips are significantly more expensive than liquid laundry detergent and eco-friendly competitors like Earth Breeze. However, it’s possible to get more loads out of a single package by using half-sheets for smaller loads.
Packaging
When it comes to packaging, Tru Earth is no different than Earth Breeze. Its Eco Strips are packaged in paper envelopes that can be recycled or composted right at home!
Availability
You can purchase Tru Earth products directly through the Tru Earth website, Amazon, and other online retailers.
Tru Earth Eco Strips are also sold at a variety of physical retail locations across Canada and the United States. But the best part is that the Tru Earth website offers a convenient locator so you can quickly and easily find a stockist near you!
Where is Tru Earth made? Where is the company location?
Tru Earth’s headquarters, manufacturing and warehouse are based in British Columbia, Canada. It is rare to find manufacturing facilities in North America.
No doubt, there are great environmental advantages of such location as it reduces the impact of transportation emissions.
Brand Initiatives
With every first-time subscription, Tru Earth donates 32 loads of laundry supplies to charities throughout Canada and the rest of the world.
For more information, check out my complete Tru Earth eco strips review.
Final Thoughts on Earth Breeze vs Tru Earth
Earth Breeze and Tru Earth are excellent brands on it comes to making your laundry washing more sustainable. They are both efficient at cleaning clothes and are plastic-free, cruelty-free and committed to sustainable causes.
One of the few points of difference (at the time of writing this article) is the price. Earth Breeze is currently cheaper!
If you are interested in more comparisons between laundry detergent sheets, check out our Kind Laundry vs Tru Earth article.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there other eco-friendly laundry detergents available?
Yes! While Earth Breeze and Tru Earth are both great options, they are far from the only brands looking to eliminate plastic waste and harmful ingredients.
There are many different types of eco-friendly laundry detergent to choose from. Dissolvable sheets are just one example!
Is eco-friendly laundry detergent toxic?
Yes. At least in the sense that it should NEVER be ingested!
While eco-friendly formulas like Earth Breeze, Tru Earth or Dropps laundry pods are better for the environment, they still contain potentially toxic ingredients. Be sure to keep all laundry detergent away from curious children or pets.
Last update on 2024-04-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
