*As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. The price to you remains the same.
Earth Breeze and Dropps are fairly big names in the world of sustainable goods. They have similar pricing. The biggest difference is Earth Breeze comes in dissolvable sheets, while Dropps comes in a pod. Dropps is US made, while Earth Breeze is made in China.
Let’s have a closer look at them!
Both Earth Breeze and Dropps are mainstays on lists of the top eco-friendly laundry detergents available. But how do you choose just one sustainable laundry detergent to replace your current go-to?
Looking for a cheaper eco-friendly alternative with a stripped-down ingredients list and minimal packaging? We recommend Earth Breeze.
Looking for a diverse range of laundry detergents all made in the US? We recommend Dropps. There’s no doubt local production can minimize emissions caused by international transportation.
Of course, there’s much more to be learned about these revolutionary laundry detergent companies! Before we go into the detailed stuff, here’s everything you need to know about Earth Breeze vs Dropps:
Earth Breeze Vs Dropps: A Comparison
|Formulas||Fresh scent, fragrance-free||Stain&odor, Sensitive Skin, |
Active Wash, Small load
|Loads per package||60||56, 64 or 80|
|Cost per load||$0.33 or $0.22 with subscription|
(check discount link below)
|$0.31 to $0.42 or $0.23 to $0.32 with subscription)|
|Packaging||Cardboard envelope||Cardboard box|
|Ingredients||8 (excluding fragrance)||16 or 7 for the Sensitive Skin formula|
|Shelf Life||Up to 18 months||Up to three years|
|Safe for HE washers||Yes||Yes|
|Safe for greywater||Yes||Yes|
|Safe for handwashing||Yes||Yes|
Laundry Pods Vs Laundry Sheets — Is One Better?
Specific brands aside, is there a clear winner between laundry detergent pods and sheets?
Laundry detergent sheets (like those sold by Earth Breeze and Tru Earth) are often deemed more sustainable because of how lightweight and compact they are. This means a smaller carbon footprint when transporting the sheets from the original factory or to consumers’ doors.
Many detergent pods sold in supermarkets are filled with unnecessary ingredients. These ingredients may include bulky fillers, dyes, fragrances, and more.
Fortunately, eco-friendly detergent pods – Dropps is one of them – offset these potential shortcomings by using fewer ingredients and/or being manufactured in close proximity to the majority of their consumers.
So instead of naming one type of detergent as inherently better than the other, here are some questions we recommend asking yourself:
- Am I buying from an overall sustainable brand?
- Is the product made in the US (or local to me)?
- What type and number of ingredients is the detergent made of?
- How is the detergent packaged?
Earth Breeze is a company committed to eliminating plastic waste — starting with liquid laundry detergent jugs.
Earth Breeze currently offers dissolvable laundry detergent sheets. It gives back by participating in initiatives that plant trees and deliver laundry detergent to those in need.
Check out our in-depth Earth Breeze review to learn more about Earth Breeze and its eco-friendly mission!
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets are available in two formulas: Fresh Scent or Fragrance-Free. There is no difference between these formulas outside of the fragrance (or lack thereof).
Don’t let Earth Breeze’s sparse product line turn you away — in many ways, it’s a plus!
Each Earth Breeze sheet consists of just 8 ingredients (plus fragrance, if applicable). All of these ingredients are vegan.
While Earth Breeze outshines the vast majority of laundry detergents in terms of ingredients, there’s still room for improvement! Namely, when it comes to the use of petroleum-derived ingredients like polyvinyl alcohol and polyethylene glycol.
Earth Breeze products are packaged in lightweight, compostable cardboard envelopes. Earth Breeze packaging is entirely plastic-free.
On average, Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets cost $.33 per load. This drops to $.22 with a subscription through the Earth Breeze website by clicking the link below which gives you a discount.
Where Are They Made?
Currently, all Earth Breeze products are manufactured in China. Although carbon emissions related to transportation are higher compared to locally-produced goods, ‘made in China’ is not necessarily a bad thing if manufacturing conditions favor that direction.
Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets are shipped to consumers from warehouses in the United States and the United Kingdom.
Where Are They Sold?
You can purchase Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets through the company website or via online retailers like Amazon.
Earth Breeze is also sold at a variety of retailers around the world. The best way to learn where Earth Breeze is stocked in your area is to contact local natural goods stores.
As one of the first companies to offer dissolvable laundry detergent pods, Dropps is directly responsible for reducing the number of plastic jugs being thrown out each day.
Along with laundry detergent, Dropps offers sustainably packaged dishwashing detergent, laundry softener, and more.
Be sure to check out our hands-on Dropps review which includes their laundry pods and dishwashing detergent! Dropps also produces a sustainable fabric softener and oxi-booster, an eco-friendly alternative to bleach.
Dropps Laundry Detergent comes in several different formulas to meet a range of household needs. The main product lines include Stain & Odor, Sensitive Skin, and Active Wash.
Each formula is available in a variety of scents, plus an Unscented version.
If standard-sized pods tend to be too big for your laundry needs, you’ll be happy to learn that Dropps has smaller versions of its Stain & Odor (Clean & Crisp scented) and Sensitive Skin (Unscented) formulas!
While the number of ingredients in Dropps Laundry Detergent varies, most formulas contain 6 to 8 ingredients (excluding fragrance).
Like Earth Breeze, Dropps pods are formulated with polyvinyl alcohol and polyethylene glycol.
All ingredients used in Dropps laundry detergent are vegan.
Dropps Laundry Detergent is packaged in 100% compostable cardboard boxes. These boxes are made using approximately 50% post-consumer recycled cardboard.
Dropps packaging can be recycled or composted at home just like any other cardboard waste.
With the sheer number of formulas available, the cost per load of Dropps laundry detergent varies. On average, Dropps pods cost the same per load as Earth Breeze sheets both with and without a subscription.
Depending on formula and order size, most Dropps pods cost between $.31 and $.42 per load. This cost drops to between $.23 and $.32 per load when you set up a recurring subscription.
Where Are They Made?
Everything from Dropps is made in the US! All products are shipped from the company’s warehouse in Chicago, Illinois.
Where Are They Sold?
At the moment, Dropps only sells its products online.
After comparing these two brands and their respective products, it’s clear that either would be a great choice for anyone interested in ditching traditional laundry detergent.
Earth Breeze stands out with its lightweight packaging and simplified ingredients list. (But you can get the same simplicity from a product made in the U.S. with Dropps Sensitive Skin formula.)
Meanwhile, the Dropps product lineup is far more extensive than that offered by Earth Breeze.
You can replace several household products — i.e., fabric softener, bleach, and dishwashing detergent — with more sustainable versions from Dropps with a single order.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will Laundry Sheets/Pods Dissolve In Cold Water?
According to both Earth Breeze and Dropps, yes! All of their laundry detergent formulas are designed to dissolve at any temperature.
Does Dissolvable Laundry Detergent Leave Behind A Film?
The most likely cause of laundry detergent build-up is using too much product for the machine.
When used correctly, laundry detergent sheets and pods are no more likely to leave a residue in your washing machine than any other detergent.
With that said, it’s just as important to use the recommended amount of detergent per load when using sheets or pods as with any other product!